Faith | Freedom | Family

NO HIDING: Finding Faith & Freedom to walk out an authentic relationship with God, His Family, and His Word. Through: Biblical Studies | Stories | Scholarship

Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Study. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Study. Show all posts

Saturday, May 3, 2025

The Interpretive Question: How to understand the Bible, methodically.

There is critical thinking (textual criticism) and then there is outright skepticism.


When scholars like Bart D. Ehrman or Daniel McClellan make big sweeping claims, like "The Bible never..." or "There are no data that support..." or "Jesus nowhere said..." or "The scholarly consensus is..."; they are speaking scholar-eese.

The thing is, a lot of what they say is accurate. Sometimes, however, their commitment to a particular worldview or bias shows, and this is where it gets interesting. We have our own commitments to worldviews and biases. You'll hear Dan say that certain claims are just "dogma", but he never admits that his own biases are dogma as well.

Textual Criticism is good, it asks us to throw off dogma, assumptions, biases, and ask what's really going on in, behind, and in front of the text. It asks us to be willing to change our understanding of what we see in the text. This is healthy skepticism.

Then there is unhealthy skepticism that assumes the worst possible about a thing from moment one. Scholars sometimes over-react to the dogma of the church with their own dogma against the church.

When you hear me or anyone else use sweeping claims, exaggeration of evidence, hasty generalizations, false dichotomies (must be this or that), absolutisms (always, never, none), it is an indication that we are likely tending toward the unhealthy skepticism side of the pendulum.

Unhealthy: There is no evidence for... All scholars agree...

    Hint: I've read a lot of scholars, there is no such thing as consensus. You can have majority and minority. You can even have either no representation of an idea, or such little representation for it that it is fringe. But you cannot have 100% unanimity on any position or claim.

Healthy: Most scholars (or most scholars I've read within my circle of influence) agree about...

Healthy: Scholars generally agree that interpretation D is not textually valid, but they usually land divided between A, B. and C. I lean toward C for the following reasons...

Healthy: Group-A makes this claim. I (being in Group-B) think that claim is nonsensical and the data do not support that claim. Here is what I see in the data. I want to freely admit to the biases, worldviews, and assumptions I am bringing to the conversation, and why I outright reject some or all of Group-A's claims.


Missing Data

It is often the case that as I read Group-A (Dogmatic holding to Church traditions) and Group-B (dogmatic holding to secular positions), that I see them as the same group.

I look for scholars who freely to admit to how often they've changed their mind or changed a position upon new evidence. I look for scholars who show which positions they've considered and why they chose the position they arrived at, up to this point.

I often find that people who arrived in a different position I did have either (1) never heard of the data I've considered or (2) have heard it and have reasons for rejecting it, reasons which I would like to know and understand. I may or may not agree with their reasons, but I want to understand it. Understanding it will either strengthen my view of the data, or, cause me to reject my view for a more accurate view. 

We must find a balance.

Dogmatic Churchianity and Dogmatic Secular Skepticism are both extremes.

So, how do we find that balance?

Simple ask one simple but difficult Interpretive Question:
  • What is this author attempting to communicate to this author's audience?
We...
    • Don't assume that this author is attempting to mislead us.
    • Don't assume this author is intending to be literal or historical.
    • Do assume that this author has a worldview and is operating within the literary conventions of their time and place.
    • Do assume that this author has an audience, and is attempting to communicate some idea or emotion or construct to their audience in the manner which is common for them.

To answer the Interpretive Question is less simple:

This requires us to start asking increasingly complicated questions that require PhD(s) and several lifetimes worth of study. We simply don't live 2000+ years ago, in a non-English speaking part of the world, without modern assumptions. The past is a foreign world, and they did things differently there.

So, we get as much material as we can, compiled by thousands of people who've done those PhD(s) in various different fields attempting to answer aspects of the questions, and we call those compilations by names like:
  • Dictionary
  • Lexicon
  • Commentary
  • Monograph
  • Journal Article
  • Textual Notes
  • Among other names... 

Then we sift through those works, understanding that some of the PhD(s) will have the same level of bias that a Flat Earther has, but most of them will provide us with good data we can use to answer the questions we'll need to ask.


Redactors and Authorial Goals


Also, we refuse to think of "The Bible" as one monolithic work. We understand that each "book" was originally a scroll or document in its own right. Even that "book" or scroll may have originally been many other works that are lost to history, and what we have is a compilation by some final editor or redactor.
ChatGPT Explains Redactor: A redactor is someone who collects, arranges, modifies, and combines source materials (oral or written traditions) into a new, cohesive literary work. This person isn't just correcting grammar or updating words—they're shaping theological meaning, narrative flow, and even historical framing.
In any given text, we are seeing potentially several source documents underneath that text, plus editors along the way who make editorial inserts (look in the Tanakh for "to this day"). We are also seeing redactors who compiled these into a final work of some kind for some kind of purpose. It is ultimately these redactors who play the most crucial role in the document we have in its final form.

We can begin to ask questions that will help us start to understand the world, worldview, purposes, and goals of the authors/editors/redactors who gave us this final text document.


Interpretive Questions

This is how we start digging into the Interpretive Question, and this can take a lifetime, so we take bite sized pieces.

Here are just a few of the kinds of questions we can begin to ask of the text:
  • What can we know about the author(s), editors, and redactors?
  • What can we know about the time period the text is speaking about?
  • What can we know about the time period of the author and intended audience, and how might that be different that the time period of the narrative/text?
  • What are some plausible things we can understand about the author and audience?
  • What kinds of rhetorical goals might this author have in communicating with their audience(s)? Are there things we know about the larger culture, or clues within the text itself to help us answer that question?
  • What genre, style, and conventions that other authors in that period are following, how does this author follow or diverge from those?
  • What level of detail or historicity can/should we expect of any author from this time period, in this part of the world?
  • What are the author's rhetorical goals?
  • What other texts (either in the target language, or in languages adjacent to the target languages/context) might this author be aware of, or be drawing inspiration from?
  • What are the worldview elements that everyone in this and surrounding cultures just assume is correct, such that it is adopted and brought into the text without question?
  • What are the semantic ranges of the keywords in the target text's language, and how might that semantic range flavor our understanding in the translated language (English in our case)?
These are just some entry level questions, there are many hundreds or thousands of other questions, depending on where these might lead.

We have to admit that these are ancient peoples writing within their genres and contexts, and not assume they are doing something a modern would do while also not assuming they are completely fabricating everything to lie to us. They're just not us.

Closing thoughts...

What are some conclusion that I've arrived at, in which I might still change my mind but this is where I land today?

  • Genesis 1-11 was written during the Babylonian exile and is fiction to make a theological point as it interacts with the shared cultural worldview of that time and place.
  • The earth is billions of years old; it was not created in 6-literal days 6,000 years ago. Augustine agrees with me. But more importantly, the author of Genesis 1 wasn't making that claim. That is you doing poor Bible reading in English Bibles without even bothering to compare all the creation narratives (including Psalms). Even a rudimentary comparison of Genesis 1 and 2 would tell you that kind of reading has issues from square one. Is it an interpretive option? Maybe, if you throw out the Interpretive Question and adopt a less academic process for your reading. I just don't see how you arrive at that conclusion when you really take the text seriously. I do see how people arrive there, I did for years, but it requires not knowing the Interpretive Question, or even how to read very well.
  • Genealogies in Matthew and Luke are fiction, they are narrative devices to show a theological linkage between Jesus and the story of Israel, they are not intended by the authors to be literal history.
  • Some scholars work very hard to prop-up Dispensational Theology that produces concepts like a "Rapture" and "7-Year Tribulation". I simply cannot see that as a viable reading of the texts in their original contexts. I would not even consider those to be among the viable interpretive choices, based on the data. I understand well-meaning people see it differently. I would love and respect those people but would avoid them as teachers. Why? Because the commitments they had to make to arrive at those conclusions will mean that they are not faithfully engaging with the Interpretive Question as outlined above.
  • The Jewish Rabbi, Yeshua (Iesos/Jesus) was a real individual in the 1st century, he was killed by the Romans in the 30s AD. Most scholars, even secular scholars, do find agreement on this point.
  • Unlike the secular scholars (who have a worldview and pre-commitment against miracles as a viable interpretive option), I have seen the risen Jesus with my own eyes. I believe he died, rose bodily, and is returning bodily to earth someday.
    • That is a bias and commitment I bring to the interpretive question.
    • Is it possible that I hallucinated as a child and the core-memory childhood imagination is now driving my interpretative choices? Yes. That's possible. I have checked with both my gut and trained therapists, and I don't believe this is the case. However, it could be. Nevertheless, I do believe my experience(s) to be legitimate and thus they do drive some of my pre-assumptions; or at least, they force me to consider as possible things that secular scholars reject as possible without considering them.

This last part is what I mean by being critical without being skeptical. If you want to begin the Interpretive Question by claiming that miracles are impossible and therefore all such claims are fabrications or hallucinations, that is fine. But you cannot claim that you are more objective than the dogmatic Young Earther. You should admit that you are bringing that bias to your research and claims. Own it, and don't try to hide behind scholarly consensus. We all have biases, own yours, and your conclusions will be more honest (No Hiding). 

To find people who are asking good questions, check out my resource pages linked here:





Shalom שָׁלוֹם: Live Long and Prosper!
Darrell Wolfe
Storyteller | Writer | Thinker | Consultant | Freelancer | Bible Nerd *Written withs some editing and research assistance from ChatGPT-4o



Wednesday, October 23, 2024

John-Revelation as a diptych (δίπτυχον)? An exploratory conversation with ChatGPT.

I've been listening to a series on John-Revelation by Dr Gregory Hall at Rethinking Scripture podcast. Hall mentions a work by Warren A. Gage: John's Gospel: A Neglected Key to Revelation? | Logos Bible Software




That got me thinking about the late great Dr Michael Heiser's series on Revelations use of the Tanakh (OT). 




And those two together got me thinking about how one of Michael Heiser's key contributions besides his specific work on the Divine Council Worldview was to teach us just how much we imposed modern contexts and later traditions on the biblical authors, and miss most of what the biblical authors are actually saying.

I think that Gregory Hall and his seminary professor (see that linked podcast above) may be correct, that we've been misunderstanding John-Revelation. 

Both The Gospel of John and Revelation have been treated as seperate niche special interests, but mostly dismissed topics. 


In New Testament studies, Paul and/or The Synoptics get all the attention. Luke-Acts has gotten a ton of attention as a diptyche. Pauline studies has exploded from the traditional view (Luther, Augustine) to the New Perspective on Paul (NPP) (EP Sanders, NT Wright), and now even Paul within Judaism "The Extreme Perspective on Paul" (Mark Nanos, Mark Kinzer, David Rudolph, Joel Willits, Joel Green, Richard Bauchman). 

Meanwhile, within secular biblical studies at least, John and Revelation are usually dismissed as later and as probably even written by separate authors, and not for the serious table. 

Outside of weird eschatology circles (#LeftBehind), Revelation is rarely taken as a serious book with serious implications for the present church.

All of the thoughts mentioned above got me into a multipronged long thread discussion with ChatGPT-4o attempting to tease out the possibilities of reading John-Revelation not as separate works by possibly separate authors, but rather, as a single work in two parts, known as a "diptych" (δίπτυχον), which Luke-Acts is widely recognized to be. 

This diptyche view of John-Revelation isn't just a minority view, it's so rare it may be considered a fringe view, if that. I've only even heard it proposed by this podcaster who had it proposed to him by his seminary professor. 

But Michael Heiser's work on the Divine Council Worldview implications of Tanakh studies was relatively unknown outside academic circles until he connected various scholars together in one work.

Could this be the same? Could there be a handful of voices each crying in the wilderness about this diptyche view, but nobody has connected all those voices and shouted it loud enough for the world to take notice? Who knows. Just wondering out loud.

The following is not an academic article by me, rather, the following is ChatGPT's own summary of our much longer thread conversation about this possibility. I believe I will write on this more but for today I wanted to post this summary as a snapshot in time so I can come back to it and ruminate.


***Below is a ChatGPT-4o Summary of my inquiry with the AI***

John and Revelation as a Diptych: A Hypothetical Reading

The concept of reading the Gospel of John and the Book of Revelation as a literary and theological diptych opens up intriguing possibilities for understanding these works as two complementary parts of a unified whole. While these texts are traditionally viewed as distinct—one a narrative about the life of Jesus, the other an apocalyptic vision of the end times—there are compelling reasons to consider them as working in tandem. By exploring their shared themes, literary structures, and historical contexts, we can propose a new reading that situates both works within the broader trajectory of early Christian reflection on Jesus and his ongoing significance in the world.

I. Historical Context and Dating

The dating of the Book of Revelation and the Gospel of John has been a subject of scholarly debate, but most scholars place their composition in the late first century AD, somewhere between AD 90 and 110. The Patristic references to both books help us narrow down these dates. Justin Martyr (AD 135-160) refers to the Logos theology central to John's Gospel, and Irenaeus (ca. AD 180) explicitly references both the Gospel of John and Revelation, attributing both to the Apostle John (Irenaeus, Against Heresies 5.30.3).

If we consider these references in light of the fact that Revelation and John were widely recognized by the mid-second century, we can infer that these works were completed and had already begun circulating no later than AD 110. This allows us to propose that the diptych could have been completed in the period AD 90-110, after the fall of Jerusalem (AD 70) and during the reigns of emperors Domitian and Trajan, when Christian communities were experiencing significant persecution.

II. Structural Parallels

One of the key reasons for viewing John and Revelation as a diptych is the remarkable structural parallels between the two works. Both texts are characterized by the use of symbolic numbers, especially the number seven, and dualistic frameworks that present cosmic conflicts between good and evil, light and darkness.

1. The Number Seven:

John's Gospel is structured around seven signs (miracles) and seven "I Am" statements (e.g., "I am the bread of life" [John 6:35], "I am the resurrection and the life" [John 11:25]). These serve to reveal Jesus' divine identity and mission.

Similarly, Revelation is organized around cycles of seven seals (Rev 6), seven trumpets (Rev 8-9), and seven bowls of wrath (Rev 16), which unfold God’s judgment and the eventual renewal of creation. These cycles emphasize completeness and divine sovereignty, themes also present in John’s Gospel.



2. Prologue and Epilogue:

Both works contain highly stylized prologues and epilogues:

John 1:1-18 opens with the famous prologue about the Logos, identifying Jesus as the Word made flesh. This introduction is theological and cosmic in scope, setting the stage for the narrative that follows.

Revelation 1:1-8 introduces the apocalyptic vision with a focus on Christ as the faithful witness and the Alpha and Omega, emphasizing his role in creation and judgment.

Both works also conclude with reflections on Christ’s ongoing presence and the ultimate fulfillment of God’s purposes (John 20:30-31; Rev 22:12-21).


III. Theological Continuity

From a theological standpoint, John and Revelation present Jesus as the central figure in God’s plan of salvation and judgment, though they do so in different ways.

1. Jesus as Creator and Consummator:

In John’s Gospel, Jesus is portrayed as the pre-existent Word, present at creation (John 1:1-3). The narrative focuses on Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection, which provide the basis for the new creation. In Revelation, Jesus is seen as the one who brings the final consummation of history, ushering in a new heaven and a new earth (Rev 21:1). Thus, the two works can be seen as bookends: John begins with creation, while Revelation ends with new creation.


2. The Lamb of God:

In John, Jesus is introduced as the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world (John 1:29). This theme is expanded in Revelation, where Jesus is repeatedly described as the slain Lamb who is victorious and worthy to open the scroll of God’s judgment (Rev 5:6-10). The motif of the Lamb, central to both texts, highlights the continuity between Jesus’ sacrificial role and his role as cosmic judge and redeemer.


IV. Revelation as Allegory of Post-70 AD History

One of the most intriguing aspects of this diptych reading is the possibility that Revelation is not primarily concerned with eschatology but is instead an allegory for post-70 AD history, using the Second Temple Jewish genre of apocalypse to tell the story of the early Christian community in the aftermath of the destruction of Jerusalem.

1. Jerusalem as Babylon:

The identification of Babylon with Rome is a common interpretation, but it is also plausible that John uses Babylon as a symbol for Jerusalem, which had become, in the eyes of early Christians, a place of rejection and judgment after the crucifixion of Jesus and the destruction of the temple. The fall of Babylon in Revelation 17-18 could be read as an allegorical account of Jerusalem’s destruction by the Romans in AD 70.


2. Rome and Christian Persecution:

Revelation’s depiction of Rome as the Beast and its persecution of Christians reflects the realities of early Christian life under Roman rule. This apocalyptic imagery can be read as describing the trials of the post-70 AD church, particularly during the reigns of Domitian and Trajan, who persecuted Christians for refusing to worship the emperor (Rev 13:4-7).


V. Stories of John’s Death and Legacy

Understanding John’s death also informs our reading of this diptych. According to Eusebius (Ecclesiastical History 3.23), John lived to a ripe old age and died a natural death in Ephesus during the reign of Trajan (ca. AD 98-117). This tradition supports the view that John authored both the Gospel and Revelation during his later years. Other legends, such as his attempted martyrdom in boiling oil, reflect the trials faced by early Christian leaders but ultimately serve to emphasize John’s role as the enduring witness to Jesus' life and message.

Conclusion

By reading John and Revelation as a diptych, we can see these two works as two sides of the same theological and literary coin. John introduces Jesus as the divine Logos who brings light into the world, while Revelation presents Jesus as the victorious Lamb who brings judgment and renewal to creation. The structural parallels, shared themes, and historical context support this reading, suggesting that both works reflect the struggles and hopes of the early Christian community in the late first century, particularly in the aftermath of Jerusalem’s destruction and during the persecutions under Rome. This reading deepens our understanding of the Johannine corpus and offers new ways of interpreting these texts in relation to each other.